The alternative to Excel for an SME's cash flow is software that builds the report from the bank statements, rather than relying on figures copied in by hand. The switch pays off once the spreadsheet covers several accounts, several tabs and only one person who knows how to keep it going. To choose, compare where the numbers come from, how transactions are categorised, whether each figure in the report opens the transactions behind it and whether Excel remains available as an export.
For many companies, Excel is the first treasury tool, and with good reason. It is flexible and everyone knows how to use it. This article does not assume you need to drop it. It explains when it stops being enough, which alternatives exist, what cash flow software should offer and how to make the move without losing your history.
When does Excel stop being enough?
A cash flow report shows, month by month, how much came into and went out of the business, grouped into lines such as sales, suppliers, salaries or taxes, with the closing balance for each month. In a spreadsheet, every one of those figures is typed or pasted in by someone. The problem is rarely the formulas. It is the work of feeding the file.
Five signs suggest the spreadsheet has reached its limit.
- The report is always behind. Transactions go in once a month, when someone has the time, and management decides on figures that are weeks old.
- There are several accounts and banks. Each statement arrives in a different format, and pulling them together takes hours before any analysis starts.
- The totals do not match the bank. A row pasted twice, or a formula that no longer covers the right range, only comes to light at month end.
- Nobody knows what sits inside each line. The report says how much suppliers cost in March, but finding the payments behind that figure means searching another tab.
- The file depends on one person. When that person is on holiday, the report stops.
If two or three of these sound familiar, it is worth looking at the alternatives.
What alternatives to Excel are there?
The options fall into four groups, and they do not all solve the same problem.
| Alternative | What it solves | What to weigh up |
|---|---|---|
| A more complete Excel template, with macros | Saves on formulas and tidies the layout | Transactions are still entered by hand, and the file still depends on whoever built it |
| Reports from the invoicing software | Show what has been invoiced and what is still to be collected | They do not see supplier payments, salaries or taxes, which sit in the bank |
| The ERP's treasury module | Connects treasury with accounting and purchasing | Needs set-up and training, and management does not always use it day to day |
| Treasury and reconciliation application | Builds the cash flow from the statements and links each transaction to the document that explains it | Does not issue invoices or replace the accounting |
The question that separates these options is where the numbers come from. A cash flow report is only reliable when it starts from what actually happened in the bank accounts, and the statement is the most complete record of that.
What should cash flow software offer?
Seven criteria separate software that replaces the spreadsheet from software that merely imitates it.
- The numbers come from the statements. It imports each account's statement in the format the bank provides, such as CSV, Excel, CAMT.053, MT940 or PDF, without duplicating transactions already imported.
- The lines are the company's own. Categories can be edited, ideally on two levels, so that the new report looks like the one management already reads.
- Recurring transactions categorise themselves. Rules based on description, amount or direction handle the rent, salaries or electricity, and the rest is left for review.
- Every figure opens the transactions behind it. Spreadsheets rarely offer this, and it is what ends arguments about a number.
- Balances show per account and consolidated. With the closing balance for each month, and no manual sums across tabs.
- The forecast is kept apart from actuals. What has happened and what is expected to come in or go out are not mixed, and overdue amounts do not inflate the forecast balance.
- Excel is still there. An Excel export keeps the analysis the company already does and lets you send the month to the accountant.
Criteria 2 and 3 matter most at the start. Our article on how to categorise bank transactions explains how to design the lines and the rules.
How do you move away from Excel without losing your history?
The move goes best in stages, with one month used for comparison.
- Copy the lines. The lines in the current report are the starting point for the software's categories. Changing the lines and the tool at the same time makes comparison impossible.
- Import the last closed month. Every account's statement for that month goes in, and each account's closing balance should match the bank's.
- Create the rules. Recurring transactions get a rule, and each correction can be saved as a new rule. By the following month, most transactions arrive already categorised.
- Compare with the old report. Put the software's cash flow and the Excel version for the same month side by side. The differences almost always point to miscategorised transactions or rows missing from the spreadsheet.
- Keep the old Excel file for reference. Previous years stay in the spreadsheet, and the software becomes the source from the first month onwards.
Before importing several months at once, check how many transactions per month the chosen plan includes.
Where does EngiFinance fit in?
EngiFinance is one of the options in the fourth group. It is an online treasury management application for SMEs that imports the company's bank statements and documents, categorises and reconciles the transactions, shows the cash flow and what is still to be collected, and prepares the monthly export for the accountant. It works without an implementation project.
- Statements. Imported as files, in CSV, Excel (.xlsx), CAMT.053 or MT940, and PDF statements are read by artificial intelligence. There is a preview before saving, transactions already imported are not duplicated and there is no need to give access to the bank accounts.
- Categories and rules. Categories on two levels, with an optional accounting code, preconfigured and editable. Rules have seven comparison types, priority, amount limits and direction, and can be tested before they are applied. Transactions without a rule can be categorised by artificial intelligence, only above the minimum confidence the organisation sets.
- Cash flow report. Monthly, by category and per year, with the balance at the end of each month and the transactions in each line. The application also shows inflows and outflows for the last 12 months, the consolidated balance and the balance per account.
- Forecast. Twelve months ahead, with inflows from invoices still to be collected and outflows from invoices still to be paid, VAT and regular payments. Overdue amounts are shown separately, outside the forecast balance.
- Export. Per month or per year, as a ZIP with an Excel of the transactions, the documents and the cash flow.
- Pricing. Per organisation, with no per-user seats and tiers based on volume. The Starter plan includes 150 transactions a month, Business 500 and Pro 2,000, and the 15-day trial uses the Business plan limits, with no card required.
EngiFinance does not issue invoices, as it reads the sales invoices issued in the software the company already uses, and it has no direct connection to banks, by product choice. It works in Portuguese, Spanish and English, on computer, tablet and mobile.
A practical example
Imagine a services company with 12 people and accounts at two banks. Its cash flow report lives in an Excel file with one tab per month, kept up to date by the office manager. Every month she downloads the statements, pastes in the transactions, assigns a line to each row and checks the totals. The report is ready around the 10th of the following month, and when the directors ask what sits inside the suppliers line, the answer takes another hour.
The company decides to test a treasury application with October, a month already closed in Excel. It copies the lines, imports both statements and creates rules for the recurring transactions. At the end it compares the two reports and finds two differences, a payment in the wrong line and a transfer between the two accounts that the spreadsheet had counted as an outflow.
In November, most transactions arrive already categorised, and the directors start opening each line to see what is inside it. Excel does not disappear. It becomes the file exported at the end of the month, instead of the place where everything is typed by hand. To look at the months ahead, our article on how to build a 12-month cash flow forecast covers the next step.
Frequently asked questions
What is the alternative to Excel for cash flow?
Treasury software that builds the cash flow report from the bank statements, using the company's own lines, rules for recurring transactions and an Excel export when needed.
When should an SME stop using Excel for cash flow?
When the report is always behind, there are several accounts and banks, the totals do not match the bank, nobody knows what sits inside each line or the file depends on a single person.
Can I keep using Excel after switching?
Yes. Software that exports the transactions and the cash flow to Excel keeps the analysis the company already does. The spreadsheet simply stops being the place where everything is typed by hand.
How do you move from Excel to software without losing history?
By copying the current lines into the categories, importing the last closed month, creating rules for recurring transactions and comparing the two reports. Previous years can stay in Excel for reference.
Does EngiFinance produce a cash flow report?
Yes. It shows a monthly cash flow report by category, per year, with the balance at the end of each month and the transactions in each line, and exports it in an Excel file with the transactions and the documents.
Does EngiFinance connect directly to the bank?
No, by product choice. Statements are imported as files, in CSV, Excel, CAMT.053 or MT940, and PDF statements are read by artificial intelligence. There is no need to give access to the bank accounts.